47 - Nov 20 thru Nov 26 2000, Vol X


Mr.
Jean-Louis Sarbib
“WB has invested one billion
dollars in Yemen, and currently we have projects that are worth of about
670 million dollars.”
World Bank contributions in Yemen started since 1995 when Yemen embarked
on the implementation of the economic reforms so as to boost its crippled
economy which had witnessed pits and falls, specially from 1990-1994. Since
that time Yemen has been following the recommendations of the World Bank
which were strongly critisized by the opposition parties as these measures
negatively affect many sections of the society increasing the number of
people below the poverty line.
Mr. Jean-Louis Sarbib, World Bank Vice President for Middle East
and North Africa came to Yemen on November 14 on a four-day visit, the
first of its kind to this country. The WB is not only working with the
government of Yemen, it also has other partners such as NGOs, a number
of companies that benefit from the funding of the WB and the communities
of Yemen. Mr. Mohammed Hatem al-Qadhi from the Yemen Times met with him
and filled the following interview:
Q: Would you tell us about the amount of money
allocated by the WB to Yemen since 1995.
A: Since the beginning of the relationship
with Yemen which is very long, the WB has invested one billion dollars
in Yemen, and currently we have projects that are worth of about 670 million
dollars that cover education, water, public works, agriculture services
to farmers, power, transpot and as a number of activities in ecomoic reform,
privatization program.. These projects disperse over a number of years
and we are very satisfied with the speed with which Yemen is using this
money.
Q: What are the main issues you discussed with
the Yemeni government?
A:We disccused the way which Yemen
needs to face the challenges of a very difficult world where the competition
is increasing. Yemen faces population explosion challenge, so it needs
a lot of economic development, it also faces the challenge of water which
could create a very big problem bacause the situation is one of the tightest,
if not the tightest in the world. And we discussed also the importance
of providing an environment where the private investment can flourish so
that jobs can be created. I discussed the importance of the authorities
attached to education, particularly education for girls. I also heard the
priority the government attaches to vocational training to help the young
people who are educated find jobs. I spent quiet a lot of time with the
social fund with the public works project because these are the kind of
projects that are creating jobs and bringing facilities, schools, roads,
health centers to many areas whic have so far not seen much in the way
of development activities.
Q: Has the WB any comment on the implementation
of economic reform program?
A: If we compare the overall ecomomic
situation of Yemen in 1994 when things were very bad, and the situation
today, I can say there is a big improvement. That improvement constitutes
the foundation of what remains to be done and there is a lot to be done.
The progress that has been made on the micro economic front is very clear
yet, it is not matched by comparable improvement in the lives of the poorest
people, so that is the challenge that is where we are working now with
the government. That why I have talked much about poverty, social fund,
public works, health, water because this is how the benefit of both microeconomic
arrangement is going to be translated into the life of the people.
Q: There are some problems facing foreign investment
like the security situation represented by kidnapping..etc. So have you
provided the government with any advice in this regard?
A: I think the government is the
first to be aware of the consequence of security situation and I don’t
think the World Bank needs to tell them. I think they are best to deal
with it. The very purpose of the ERP (Enamic Reform Program) is to imrove
the investement climate. What investors want is an environment which is
predictable, they want a legal system that works, they want their projects
to be secured. They want to be able to do their financial projectin that
is, they want to know whether there will be little inflation, budget is
to be managed well, that they will be free to import and export.
Q: Some Yemeni economists think that the project
of privatization has targeted establishments which are successful. What
is you comment?
A: Well, the goal of privatization
is to make the governmnet into a refernce and to not into an actor of commercial
activities. It is much better to leave the enterprises to the private sector
and to have the government focus on what it should do which is education,
health, provide rural roads so the farmers can have access to markets of
their projects. We worked in many countries in the world and usually privatization
at the end creates new jobs, new reliable services to the people. It is
very important to realize where enterprise loses money. It is the people
of Yemen who pay instead of getting education, health and water and services,
they pay many for people to produce roads that are so bad that the Yemeni
consumers don’t buy them.
Q: How could you distinguish between the role
of the WB and IMF?
A: Well, the IMF (Internationally
Monitary Fund) is an international organization which is concerned with
macroeconomic policy, with the budget, with monetary policy, with exchange
rate and they usually look at things because the budget is assigned yearly,
within a shorter time. The WB is much more concerned about long term development
issues that have structural measures. We have done plenty of researches
with WB that shows that when you make an investment in economy which is
not well-managed, it is a waste of money and that is doesn’t deliver benefit
for the peole. if imgine an engine of a car to be fixed, then the IMF is
concerned with the fixing the engine and the World Bank is concerned with
giving the gas to get the car moving.
Q: Every three years you have a plan for projects
to support and you assign for each plan an amount of money, how much money
the WB has assigned to the next three years?
A: The WB agrees with each country
in every three years on what is called a country system strategy which
essentially defines what the WB country agree to do together for three
years. The last one for Yemen we had it approved by the board of the WB
in August 1999. So far we believe progress has been made along the line
that we have agreed is resonable.
Q: Does the WB have a role in helping Yemen
join the WTO?
A: Well we don’t play a particular
role. If the government were to ask some of our people in Washington to
help with certain negautiating points or to provide some assistance, to
build the capacity to fulfil the conditions we will be happy to do that.
But now we are not involved.
Q: How do you explain the protest of the people
around the world to the policy of the WB, if we take into account the demonstrations
in the USA?
A: Well, I think part of it is
concerned with justice I belive it is something that we welocme in the
WB because as they said we are committed and we believe we want the same
things . which is less poverty and more equity in the world. I also think
many of these protests are very poorly informed about what the WB does.
We discussed this with about 250 NGOs: how to work together and these were
very constructive discussions. So the goal of the Bank is to recognize
that there are very serious issues of inequity in the world and to try
and make sure these issues are not ignored. What we disagree in with the
protesters is the fact we don’t believe that we contribute to creating
poverty. We believe we are doing every possible thing to keep these issues
very much inside and to try solve them. The policies of the WB are changing
all the time because on contrary to what many people think we are not dogmatic
institution, we are pragmatic institution. We want to learn from what works
and what does not work and the ground we are constantly adjusting our policies
based on the results of experience. The problems of development in Yemen,
are very difficult problems and no one has a magic al solution. But we
are working more and more in an inclusive manner and in a participatory
manner. We are trying to talk to people, NGOs and communities look at the
activities of the Social Fund and public works, these are the activities
the WB is pushing.
The role of journalism in this regard is very important. We have a
program in the WB for MENA region to provide an economic training for journalists
to organize seminars and try to get people to understand what the WB is
and at the same time I belive it is the responsibility of the governments
to explain to their peole their policies and not to hide behind the WB.
Q: How do you explain the protest of the people
around the world to the policy of the WB, if we take into account the demonstrations
in the USA?
A: Well, I think part of it is
concerned with justice I belive it is something that we welocme in the
WB because as they said we are committed and we believe we want the same
things . which is less poverty and more equity in the world. I also think
many of these protests are very poorly informed about what the WB does.
We discussed this with about 250 NGOs: how to work together and these were
very constructive discussions. So the goal of the Bank is to recognize
that there are very serious issues of inequity in the world and to try
and make sure these issues are not ignored. What we disagree in with the
protesters is the fact we don’t believe that we contribute to creating
poverty. We believe we are doing every possible thing to keep these issues
very much inside and to try solve them. The policies of the WB are changing
all the time because on contrary to what many people think we are not dogmatic
institution, we are pragmatic institution. We want to learn from what works
and what does not work and the ground we are constantly adjusting our policies
based on the results of experience. The problems of development in Yemen,
are very difficult problems and no one has a magic al solution. But we
are working more and more in an inclusive manner and in a participatory
manner. We are trying to talk to people, NGOs and communities look at the
activities of the Social Fund and public works, these are the activities
the WB is pushing.
The role of journalism in this regard is very important. We have a
program in the WB for MENA region to provide an economic training for journalists
to organize seminars and try to get people to understand what the WB is
and at the same time I belive it is the responsibility of the governments
to explain to their peole their policies and not to hide behind the WB.
|